Custom birthday cakes in Naples, Florida

Crowns, butterflies, florals, big numbers, a favorite sport, or something completely new. Nica makes every birthday cake to order, with the name, age, colors, and theme you want.

Start my orderText 239-269-3060
Lavender birthday cake with a gold Happy Birthday topper, lavender and gold spheres, and gold-edged butterflies.
Lavender and gold butterflies

From Nica’s kitchen

Real orders, made in Naples. Every one was designed around the customer’s idea.

  • White birthday cake with gold Birthday Queen lettering, gold pearls, and a jeweled crown on top.
    Birthday queen
  • Tall lavender buttercream cake with a printed calendar on top marking the birthday, piped ruffles, silver butterflies, and a glitter Happy Birthday topper.
    Birthday calendar
  • White textured cake ringed with pink buttercream roses and baby’s breath.
    Pink roses
  • Pink buttercream birthday cake topped with kiwi, strawberries, and blackberries, with a gold Happy Birthday topper.
    Fresh fruit on top
  • White Happy Birthday cake with piped rosettes and pearls, surrounded by matching white cupcakes.
    Cake with matching cupcakes
  • Purple birthday cake with gold Happy Birthday lettering, a large gold 20 topper, and blue and gold spheres.
    Big number birthday
  • Yellow basketball birthday cake with player silhouettes, a hoop topper, a basketball, and gold spheres.
    Basketball fan
  • Small cake shaped like a pink teacup on a saucer, filled with pink buttercream roses.
    Teacup cake

How it works

Every order is custom and quoted personally.

  • Your design

    Names, ages, colors, toppers, and themes are all made to order. Send a photo of something you love and Nica will design around it.

  • Size

    Cakes are sized to your guest count, from a small celebration cake to a tiered party cake. Tell Nica how many people you’re serving.

  • Add-ons

    Add matching cupcakes, cake pops, chocolate-covered strawberries, or a full dessert table in the same theme.

  • Timing

    Order at least 2 weeks before the birthday. A 50% deposit reserves your date.

  • Pickup or delivery

    Pick up in Naples, or have it delivered. Delivery starts at $25 and covers Naples, Marco Island, Bonita Springs, Fort Myers, Cape Coral, and nearby towns.

Good to know

Where can I order a custom birthday cake in Naples, FL?

Nica’s Creamy Creations & More makes custom birthday cakes to order in Naples, Florida, for kids and adults. Send your date and your idea through the order form, or text 239-269-3060, and you’ll get a personal quote.

Can you put a name or age on the cake?

Yes. Names, ages, colors, toppers, and themes are all part of the custom design. Send an inspiration photo with your request.

Do you make matching cupcakes?

Yes. Matching cupcakes, cake pops, strawberries, and dessert tables can be added in the same colors and theme.

How far ahead should I order a birthday cake?

At least 2 weeks before the birthday. Need it sooner? Text 239-269-3060 and Nica will tell you if it’s possible.

How much does a custom birthday cake cost?

Every cake is quoted individually, based on your date, how many people you’re serving, and the design. There’s no fixed price list. Delivery starts at $25.

Start your order

Send your date and your idea. Nica will reply with a personal quote.

Open the order formText 239-269-3060